It is finally here! In 2005 Keith Mathison edited When Shall These Things Be?: A Reformed Response to Hyper-Preterism. This book was advertised as the definitive, scholarly response to Covenant Eschatology. Plans were made by others to respond, but for various reasons a response was not forthcoming. Now, however, at long last, four Reformed authors respond, in a very powerful way, to When Shall These Things Be?